TPM Online
 [Home] [Articles] [Café] [Games] [Portals] [Quotations] [Archive] [Potpourri]    [TPM Shop] [Link To Us!] [Feedback] [Contact Us ]

Mason's MeditationsMason's Meditations

If you're looking for something to chew over, some thoughtful seeds for mental cultivation, bookmark this page for Jeff Mason's monthly meditations. To think in or take away...

Number Thirty Four: The Indifference of Nature

Stand back and look at the universe as a whole. What do you see? On the best scientific hypothesis now available, the universe is made up of matter and energy, and is, on the micro level, quite chaotic. Chance rules. There is no intention behind the universe, no mind that has willed things for the best. The laws of nature are contingent upon the universe being what it is, and it might, metaphysically speaking, have been quite different. In vain do we look for Providence in the workings of nature. Earthquakes, mud slides, microbes, carnivores, floods and accidents make things worse for human beings pure and simple. They deliver undeniable blows to our plans, families and lives. What good is there in these things? None, to my reckoning.

Equally, we might ask what evil there is in these things. The natural disasters that strike us down are not always our responsibility. The tree that falls on a pedestrian intends no harm. It simply obeys the law of gravity. The SARS virus is just trying to make a living and will spread where it can for its own survival. The tornado gives no thought to the destruction it causes, for it is we who see destruction in the clouds.

In geological time, there has been a parade of species marching through the pages of Natural History. They come into being and go out of being with alarming rapidity, though some life forms find a shape so stable that they remain essentially unchanged for millions of year. The Trilobites are a good example, but they, too, eventually went the way of the Giant Sloth, whose term on earth was much shorter. Nature does not care about itself, needs to take no care for itself, and is supremely indifferent to all that happens within it.

Nature wishes us no harm, nor any benefit, either. The vaunted "dominant species on earth" is just another species in the parade, and will have its run. Only time can say whether this species will last as long as the Trilobites or the Giant Sloth. As long as we are able, we will strive to endure, to exist, and to propagate our species. I am sure we will go down fighting. Yet it is our fight, and we fight it for ourselves and our species. Nature, being indifferent to us, will not deign to fight. It is no good complaining about this. There simply are no hidden silver linings in disasters. We, too, are part of nature and will run the course, just as we shall all continue to live until our bodies give out on us. This is not good, not bad, but simply the way it is for mortals, no matter how long their lives may be. Our job is to make things better for ourselves and for others while we live. Nature will take care of the rest, without a care of its own.

To comment on this Meditation, click here.

Click here to return to the Philosophy Café

Mason's Meditations will next be updated mid July 2003

 

Join Our Café mailing list

To receive *very* short messages, letting you know when the Café has been updated, just fill in your email address below - and press submit.

Email Address:
Action: Subscribe | Unsubscribe

[If you wish to unsubscribe from the mailing list, simply fill in your subscriber email address, select "Unsubscribe", and press Submit.]


Previous Meditations

33. Extreme Old Age
32. The Cave
31. Do We Reap What We Sow?
30. Depth and Surface
29. Complex subjectivities
28. What To Do
27. History Happens
26. The Most Dangerous Game
25. Meditation
24. Golden Rules
23. Change
22. It's All Relative (Not)
21. To Know or Not to Know
20. Wonder
19. Dualism
18. Time and Immortality
17. Perennial Philosophy
16. Pain and Grief
15. Paradise Now
14. The Life of Pleasure
13. The Most Terrible Thing
12. Assisted Suicide
11. Death
10. Pessimism and Optimism
9. Leisure
8. The Reflective Life
7. On Having an Open Mind
6. The Art of Conversation
5. Having, Doing, Being
4. The Good of Things
3. Is Happiness Overrated?
2. The Fiction of Forevermore
1. The Art of Living

TPM Online is The Philosophers' Magazine on the net.
It is edited by Dr Jeremy Stangroom.
© The Philosophers' Magazine - 98 Mulgrave Road, Sutton, Surrey SM2 6LZ
Tel/Fax +44 (0)20 8643 1504